When Steve Jobs made the rounds of main file labels in 2000, he knew he had them over a barrel.
Music piracy, kicked into excessive gear by the unique Napster the earlier June, was a risk to the recorded music business. The brand new frontier for music was on-line and the labels have been fully ill-equipped to take care of the best shift in music distribution in a century. They needed to get in on the enterprise of promoting music digitally, however how?
Oh, the labels tried to construct their very own obtain shops, however Pressplay (initially referred to as Duet and owned by Common and Sony) and Musicnet (all the opposite majors) have been depressing failures. First, they have been costly. For $15 a month, followers may stream 500 songs every month, get 50 music downloads and the power to burn every of these songs to CD 10 instances.
Second, it was chaotic for the buyer. You wanted to know what label a music or artist was on earlier than. The phrases of use have been complicated and digital rights administration (DRM) locks on the recordsdata made transferring them round tough and irritating. It was a lot, a lot simpler to simply steal music.
Third, the labels couldn’t work collectively on a unified platform as a result of that may have violated all types of anti-trust guidelines, a authorized state of affairs that additionally assist scupper the labels’ proposed buy of Napster.
Learn extra:
Tables have turned — Vinyl information outsell CDs for 1st time since 1987
The labels had all of the digital merchandise however no method to distribute and promote them. Apple’s iTunes supplied a method out of this bind.
Jobs satisfied the labels that permitting him to promote particular person songs for 99 cents every was the best way to go. And since the labels had no thought what they have been doing — and since Apple was dedicated to spending hundreds of thousands on advertising (to not point out they’d this new gadget referred to as an iPod) — the labels all signed on with the iTunes Music Retailer.
His pitch labored, and increase — the music business modified eternally.
There had been different makes an attempt at creating digital music shops. Cductive was based in 1996 and offered MP3 downloads for 99 cents (it was acquired by eMusic in 1999). Sony debuted Bitmusic in Japan in 1999, providing principally singles from Japanese artists (it failed). Manufacturing unit Data launched Music33, which supplied downloads for 33 pence every (ditto). There was even a Canadian digital music retailer referred to as Puretracks that lasted for a few nanosecond.
Nothing beat iTunes, particularly when the labels agreed to take away all DRM locks in 2007. (I nonetheless have songs on my pc within the previous .mp4a format which might be locked up and may’t be freely transferred from one place to a different.) It quickly turned de rigueur for all releases to be obtainable by iTunes.
And since the iTunes Music Retailer was really easy to make use of on all computer systems (providing a Home windows model was an enormous deal), it turned the favorite vacation spot for purchasing digital albums and tracks. At one level, iTunes was answerable for 70 per cent of all digital music gross sales. Nearly each would-be challenger was crushed. Hey, anybody bear in mind hmvdigital.com?
However the entire shift from promoting items of plastic to digital tracks left a foul style within the mouths of the labels. They’d fully ceded distribution of their product to an outsider who charged a 30 per cent fee on every file offered. They vowed by no means to let that occur once more.
Learn extra:
Alan Cross remembers when instrumentals nonetheless dominated the charts
Quick ahead to at this time. Streaming, not downloads, is king and the labels have agency management over how streamers might do enterprise. They made greater than US$10 billion from streaming in 2022. Additionally they constantly obtain petabytes and petabytes of knowledge on how music followers devour music.
And since streaming is so low-cost — and even free — music piracy is a fraction of what it was.
Consequently, gross sales of digital tracks and albums proceed to plummet. In Canada, the gross sales of digital albums are down 15.9 per cent from this time final 12 months and digital observe gross sales have fallen by 7.5 per cent. In the meantime, streaming is up 13.9 per cent from a 12 months in the past as Canadians reliably stream someplace round 2.3 billion songs every week.
I could make the state of affairs sound much more dire. In 2012, we purchased 1.3 billion digital tracks. Final 12 months, we purchased 152 million. That’s a crash of 88.6 per cent in a decade. These numbers clearly aren’t good. Paid downloads are shortly turning into the subsequent cassette.
Gross sales have been as soon as front-and-centre on the iTunes residence web page. Now you need to hunt a bit for the iTunes Music Retailer while you open the app. In case you go to Amazon, a seek for MP3s takes you to a web page that pushes streaming and bodily product. Neither firm breaks out how a lot digital music they promote of their monetary reviews.
So right here’s the query: How lengthy will Apple assist iTunes? Heck, how for much longer do all digital tracks/albums gross sales have? Let me situation a plea that this by no means occurs.

I desperately want iTunes to proceed due to my work. I would like to achieve full and authorized entry to songs to provide my radio present, The Ongoing Historical past of New Music, so I purchase as much as a dozen songs every week. My Mac tells me I’ve 79,655 objects taking on 564.65 gigabytes in my library. A non-insignificant variety of these songs are iTunes downloads.
There are numerous makes use of for downloads. DJs want recordsdata they will combine as a part of their units. Older music followers introduced up on a food regimen of buying CDs and vinyl additionally like iTunes as a result of it provides everlasting possession as a substitute of renting music from streamers. Insiders know that if downloads for an artist improve, it could present that the artist has crossed over to an older demo.
Artists may also see respectable income from iTunes, particularly after they’re within the information for one thing. Paid downloads spike up and so they pay out far, excess of streams. Artists, labels and managers additionally monitor iTunes for songs which will pop on iTunes’ charts, a attainable indication that one thing attention-grabbing is occurring.
Learn extra:
How did the Canadian music business do in 2022? The year-end stats are out
What are the choices if iTunes goes away as Google Play Music did? Nicely, there are different digital music storefronts. There’s the aforementioned eMusic, which got here on-line promoting DRM-free MP3s in January 1998, three years earlier than iTunes debuted. It has contracts with the foremost labels and dozens of indies. Not like iTunes and Amazon Music, it’s a download-to-own website that requires the acquisition of a month-to-month membership. Its library isn’t as deep as iTunes (15 million songs vs a minimum of 60 million) however it will probably do the job for some individuals.
Probably the most attention-grabbing digital music storefronts are these promoting hi-res lossless recordsdata for individuals who demand the very best in audio high quality. For instance, 7 Digital will promote you all types of digital music, together with loads of 24-bit FLAC recordsdata. That’s incredible — when you have the mandatory {hardware}.
The identical goes for Professional Studio Masters (I used it fairly a bit for purchasing FLAC recordsdata). If that’s your jam, you’ll want to take a look at HDTracks and France’s Qobuz. which is able to debut in Canada later this 12 months.
DJs and dance music followers have lengthy recognized about Beatport. In case you’re into the indie aspect of issues, you’ve most likely bought a obtain or two from Bandcamp. After which there’s Bleep, which focuses on impartial artists and labels.
Nonetheless, although, it’s exhausting to beat iTunes for choice and performance. I actually, actually hope Apple doesn’t do one thing silly like kill it. However with every week’s music business gross sales numbers, you need to marvel how far issues can drop earlier than it’s time to maneuver on.
If that day comes, it is going to be very, very unhappy.
—
Alan Cross is a broadcaster with Q107 and 102.1 the Edge and a commentator for World Information.
Subscribe to Alan’s Ongoing Historical past of New Music Podcast now on Apple Podcast or Google Play