With only one episode to go, we’re nearing the top of Joel and Ellie’s lengthy journey collectively. This week’s entry, “When We Are in Want,” corresponds with the sport’s winter part, although the HBO adaptation isn’t utilizing the identical seasonal construction of the sport, and right here in TV land, it’s been winter for some time.
Once I first performed The Final of Us ten years in the past, in some methods the winter chapter felt to me like overkill, the sport leaning onerous into desperation and depravity simply to be as gritty and bleak because it might, with a purpose to assist promote itself as a “mature,” critical sport. “Sufficient, I get it. Humanity is terrible and given half an opportunity, we’ll all do grotesque, morally reprehensible issues.” Replaying the sport now alongside the present, the aim of the chapter throughout the narrative is clearer to me. In fact it’s frequent for tales to place characters at their most hopeless and determined factors proper earlier than the decision, however the best way The Final of Us does it, separating the characters whereas each are in dire straits, drives residence the significance of their bond to one another. It additionally, importantly, illustrates that whereas Joel might have began out as Ellie’s protector on this journey, he now wants her a minimum of as a lot as she wants him. Let’s take a more in-depth take a look at this week’s episode, and its similarities to the identical stretch of the sport.
Ellie meets David within the present vs. the sport
This chapter has its personal villain within the type of David, a preacher and a predator whose flock reside within the resort city of Silver Lake and are struggling by a very harsh winter. When it comes to dialogue, it’s one of many present’s extra trustworthy episodes. In truth, it’s nearly as if author Craig Mazin’s screenplay for the episode simply took this part of the sport, minimize out a lot of the fight sequences, and from there, sought to decorate the dialogue and construct on what the sport reveals to us about David and his congregation. It continues to be attention-grabbing to me how, within the sport, fight is probably prioritized as an important component, whereas in adapting the sport to a sequence, it turns into the least necessary.
The winter chapter instantly distinguishes itself from the remainder of the sport by having you play as Ellie for the primary time. (Right this moment, enjoying by the story so as, you’d play the Left Behind DLC earlier than this, however when the sport got here out in 2013, this was a shocking shift in perspective.) Determined for meals, Ellie hunts a deer she spots within the woods together with her bow and arrows. Nicked and bleeding from a number of arrows, the deer runs, finally collapsing, however when Ellie finds it, two others, David and James, have seen it too. Simply as within the sport, David (voiced right here by Nolan North, who performs Nathan Drake in Naughty Canine’s Uncharted video games) makes a cope with Ellie: penicillin for among the deer meat.
G/O Media might get a fee
What’s distinctive to the sport is that whereas ready for James to return with the drugs, you’ve got a multi-stage fight encounter preventing alongside David, involving a number of standoffs towards a number of waves of contaminated and a climactic battle with a bloater. By means of all of it, you may suppose that David is definitely a brand new good friend. He appears genuinely involved on your welfare, and preventing alongside somebody could be an expertise that develops belief. Naughty Canine is aware of easy methods to use fight as a device for relationship-building, and right here, they construct up your belief in David a bit simply to tug out the rug from below you and remind you that, on this world, the belief between Joel and Ellie is a uncommon and valuable factor.
Within the present, by the point Ellie first encounters David (performed right here by actor Scott Shepherd), we have already got our causes to be suspicious of him. The episode begins with him studying scripture to his flock, within the previous steakhouse he’s transformed right into a church and city corridor of types, a spot the place the considerable meals of the pre-cordyceps previous is sharply contrasted with the determined circumstances of the current. (It’s an necessary location within the sport as effectively, one you come to later, and the signal studying WHEN WE ARE IN NEED HE SHALL PROVIDE is a element straight from the sport.) The faces of the congregation’s members are lean and hardened, telling us a lot at a look about what a troublesome winter they’re having. A grieving daughter asks when her father could be buried and David says that it’s too chilly to take action now, they’ll have to attend till spring. And outdoors after the service, David chides James (performed by Troy Baker, the voice of Joel within the video games) for his “doubt,” giving off the sense of a person who very a lot desires to take care of management.
Notably, within the present, Ellie hunts the deer not with a bow and arrows however with the sniper rifle, recalling in our reminiscences the second towards the top of episode six when Joel tried to show her easy methods to use it. When she takes a second to focus with the deer in her sights, we will sense her recalling Joel’s phrases and attempting to attract on what he taught her.
Each the sport and the present have Ellie speaking robust when she sees David and James close to the deer she killed, together with her calling James “buddy boy” and saying that if David tries something, she’ll “put one proper between your eyes.” The present, nonetheless, foregrounds David’s position as a preacher of their first dialog excess of the sport does. In truth, maybe the one actual trace David offers off within the sport that he has sure inflexible ethical requirements may come when, after Ellie swears, he absurdly says, within the midst of a life-and-death battle towards waves of contaminated, that she ought to watch her language. We undoubtedly decide up on the truth that he’s a preacher finally, however there’s no actual character growth executed round it.
Within the present, nonetheless, Ellie asks if David’s “starvation membership” is a few type of cult, and he activates the folksy appeal, saying “Properly, you sorta kinda acquired me there,” however saying that what he preaches is “fairly normal Bible stuff.” When Ellie wonders how he can nonetheless “imagine that stuff” after every little thing that’s occurred, he tells her it was truly after the world ended that he began to imagine. “All the things occurs for a purpose,” he says in each the present and the sport, and it’s right here that no matter sense of belief you may need felt for David whereas preventing alongside him possible evaporates. His seeming friendliness reveals itself to be a guise for one thing extra threatening, and he tells her {that a} “loopy man” killed somebody of their flock lately on the college. A loopy man who simply occurs to be touring with a “little woman.”
Ellie now understands that David is a risk if she didn’t earlier than, however David lets her journey off with the drugs, telling her that there’s room for her in his group, that he can defend her. It’s nearly as if he has some gross designs of his personal for her.
Dinnertime on the steakhouse
One of many luxuries of HBO’s adaptation has at all times been that it could actually go away the angle of Joel and Ellie behind completely when it desires to, and right here, we get extra growth of David’s congregation. Within the kitchen, members of the flock lament their dwindling meals provides, and when a person brings in some recent meat, considered one of them asks, “What’s it?” “Venison,” he replies hesitantly, in a means which will have you ever asking, “Is it although?” Nonetheless, they put it into the night’s soup.
David and James haul the deer Ellie killed into the restaurant, however the room nonetheless appears quiet. Sensing what the stress is about, David tells them that sure, it’s true, “we discovered the woman who was with the person who took Alec from us.” Come morning, he says, they’ll monitor her path, and “carry that man to justice.” The grieving woman from the opening scene raises her voice, saying they need to kill each of them. David walks over and, in a second that exhibits us simply what sort of congregation chief he’s, backhands her throughout the face. Issues worsen nonetheless a second later when he tells her that though she might imagine she doesn’t have a father anymore, “the reality is, Hannah, you at all times have a father. And you’ll present him respect when he’s talking.” Kenneth is just not fallacious when he says the present makes David much more disturbing than he already was.
The scene ends with pictures of those hungry individuals consuming their dinners, the thought lingering in our minds that it might be Alec they’re consuming.
Hungry…for vengeance!
The following morning, David’s males do certainly come a-huntin’. In each the present and the sport, Ellie does the one factor she will be able to suppose to do: strive main the lads away from Joel, who she’s injected with penicillin however who remains to be hovering on the sting of consciousness. Within the present, she presses a knife into his palms and tells him to kill anybody who comes into the home, although he doesn’t even appear to be he has the energy to take a seat up.
The present offers us one other temporary alternate between David and James, as David insists that Ellie be introduced in alive. James says he doesn’t imply to query David’s “sense of mercy” however the woman would simply be one other mouth to feed, and that sure, she might die if left alone out right here, however maybe that’s God’s will. David merely offers him a withering look, nevertheless it’s abundantly clear that David’s curiosity in holding Ellie alive has nothing to do with mercy.
Ellie rides by the neighborhood on her horse—the neighborhood which, within the sport, has a small military of David’s males on the streets—and finally, her horse is shot out from below her. Within the present, it’s James who does this, and David has to cease him and another males from killing Ellie. Carrying her off himself and ordering a number of males to haul the horse carcass, he tells the rest of his males to go door to door searching Joel. “You’re so hungry for vengeance? Ship it.”
Within the sport, nonetheless, one other prolonged fight sequence begins, as Ellie should sneak by or kill a variety of David’s males. What we get right here that we don’t get a lot within the present is loads of deep dissatisfaction among the many flock with David’s management, with many males expressing doubt in David and suggesting that quickly, his position as chief be put to a vote. Regardless of your greatest efforts, although, David does finally seize and subdue Ellie, whereas his personal delusions of grandeur about his personal benevolence proceed to manifest. “I’m holding you alive right here,” he says, as he jokes the consciousness out of her.
Ellie left Joel behind
In each the present and the sport, Joel lastly comes again to life, as if woke up by the cosmos simply in Ellie’s hour of want. The Police have a track about that known as “Synchronicity I,” however I digress. Within the present, some poor bearded sap enters the home the place Joel is stashed within the basement. Ellie was good and hid the door to the basement behind an previous piece of furnishings, however the poor bastard rolls effectively on his notion examine and notices one thing’s up. It will have been higher for him if he hadn’t.
As he comes down the steps, recognizing the bloody mattress Ellie’s had Joel on for days, we all know Joel has lastly regained consciousness, and is hiding down there someplace. Sure, it seems Joel has regained the energy not solely to maneuver, however to stab and choke the life out of a person. That’s the Joel we all know and love!
In the meantime, Ellie wakes up in a cage—within the sport, to the sight of a person butchering a human physique proper in entrance of her, although within the present, it’s simply David sitting there, ready for her to get up. Within the present, which continues working to make David extra overtly disturbing than he’s within the sport, he tells her that she’s in a cage as a result of “you’re a harmful individual, you’ve definitely confirmed that,” and there’s an unmistakable trace of amusement and even admiration to his remark.
Joel’s again in motion
Joel, determined to search out Ellie, tortures two of David’s males to get her whereabouts. It’s a startling juxtaposition with an alternate between Ellie and David within the sport. When Ellie calls David an animal, he protests that she and Joel have killed an amazing many individuals too. “They didn’t give us a selection, it’s a online game,” she says. (Properly, okay, she doesn’t say that second half.) “And also you suppose we have now a selection, is that it?” David says. “You kill to outlive. So will we. We have now to care for our personal, by any means vital.”
I don’t actually subscribe to that logic, however his phrases do on some degree indict Joel, I feel. Some might really feel that Joel and David are factors of distinction, one’s violence rooted in hate and delusion, the opposite’s in love and necessity. I definitely don’t suppose Joel and David are the identical, however I additionally don’t suppose there’s something harmless or acceptable about what Joel does right here. And I’m positive with that. I need characters in my media who generally do terrible issues. What’s at all times troubled me in regards to the response to Joel, although, is simply how many individuals who performed the sport appear to suppose that every little thing he does is completely justified, whereas recognizing that the actions of others on the earth aren’t. It’s as if we don’t wish to carefully interrogate the actions of the individual we play as, the one we most carefully determine with.
This can be a dialog for subsequent week’s finale, nevertheless it appears clear to me that the sport, and the present, a minimum of need us to consider the lengths Joel goes to right here, lengths that embrace brutally murdering one man after he tells Joel what he wished to know, after which killing the opposite, too. When the second man declares that he gained’t inform Joel something, each the sport and the present give us the chilling and memorable line wherein Joel, referring to the person he simply killed, says “That’s okay, I imagine him.”
Cordyceps confirmed David the sunshine
The present expands considerably on David’s dialog with Ellie, and makes it far more unsettling. He speaks to her—a 14-year-old woman—as if he sees her as some form of equal, a kindred spirit, as a result of they each have “a violent coronary heart.” He fought to restrain his violent coronary heart for a very long time, he says, earlier than he was proven the sunshine, not by God, however by cordyceps. “What does cordyceps do? Is it evil? No. It’s fruitful. It multiplies. It feeds and protects its kids. And it secures its future with violence, if it should. It loves.” I respect the enlargement of David’s concepts right here, as a result of I feel the notion that love and violence can overlap is on the core of The Final of Us, and whereas David is clearly deranged, the controversy over whether or not Joel’s violence is a manifestation of affection rages on.
David, plainly a person who’s used to having individuals reply to his charisma, makes the error of pondering that Ellie could be seduced by him as effectively, when, in each the sport and the present, he places his hand on the bars of the cage and makes it clearer nonetheless that his concepts about her are, to place it mildly, inappropriate. It’s a deeply unhappy second to me, the conclusion that even on this world the place society as we all know it has collapsed, Ellie, like most girls in our world at one time or one other, in a technique or one other, nonetheless has to cope with the risk and the supreme bullshit of predatory males. Each variations punish David for his conceitedness and delusion, as Ellie, briefly enjoying alongside, takes his hand after which snaps one thing in it earlier than lastly telling David her identify. Inform the others, she says, that “Ellie is the little woman that broke your fucking finger!”
Right here the sport begins to make use of the efficient machine of getting us swap backwards and forwards between Joel and Ellie at intervals, as Joel heads into city to search out her, killing loads of David’s males alongside the best way whereas a blizzard gathers energy, elevating the sense of drama and letting you decide off your prey within the low visibility. Sure, in fact he’s doing it for her sake, to guard her, to assist her, however by now, it additionally feels very very like he’s doing it as a result of he doesn’t know what he would do with out her. In fact traditionally, video games as soon as relied too typically on placing underdeveloped girls in peril and simply specializing in the lads who needed to rescue them, however The Final of Us earns this setup by humanizing them each, by creating their connection, and by presenting their relationship as considered one of mutual care and profit. By now, Ellie has taken care of Joel and saved his life about as a lot as he’s executed for her.
The present additionally now switches again to Joel’s perspective, exhibiting him heading into city and discovering Ellie’s stuff, to not point out human our bodies strung up on meathooks. Higher hurry, Joel.
The trick up Ellie’s sleeve
In each variations, David (with James’ assist, within the present) hauls Ellie out of the cage to chop her up into “little items,” since she didn’t take him up on his glorious supply. Simply as they’re about to begin cleaving, nonetheless, she publicizes that she’s contaminated, prompting David to roll up her sleeve and reveal the wound on her arm. David says it could actually’t be actual, James says it appears to be like fairly fucking actual to him, and that’s the very last thing he’ll ever say, as Ellie takes benefit of their second of hesitation to sink a meat cleaver into James’ neck and sprint out of the room.
Right here, the sport turns into a form of boss struggle, as Ellie should sneak across the restaurant and stealthily assault David whereas a hearth begins to unfold. Within the present, his ego extra evidently implodes because the restaurant, his church, burns down round him. It’s a breakdown on a number of ranges, with this deluded, terrible, terrifying man shouting “You don’t know the way good I’m!” In each circumstances, it’s as much as Ellie to guard herself, to defeat this supremely shitty, predatory man, whose intentions to inflict sexual violence on Ellie, implied however nonetheless clear within the sport, are made far more express within the present. And in each circumstances, it’s immensely cathartic and satisfying to see her lastly kill him, and never simply kill him however stab him repeatedly till she herself is a blood-spattered survivor, a horror film ultimate woman. However a part of what offers the ultimate woman trope its terrible efficiency is that the sorts of sexualized violence these girls so typically struggle towards can’t be killed by killing only one dangerous man. It’s a risk all of us face, on a regular basis. Ellie survives, in fact, however the stare she offers within the wake of it, the best way she reacts at first when Joel approaches her, means that she’s endlessly modified by the expertise. Ellie is all of us.
It’s okay, child woman
Joel exhibits up simply after her struggle is gained, and as refined a element as it’s, the truth that within the present, similar to within the sport, he calls her “child woman” within the wake of the horror she’s simply endured is tender and really significant. It tells us that there’s now not any pretense of division or obligation between them, of Joel doing this simply as a job, of her simply being cargo.
By placing each characters in such determined circumstances, after which having them lastly come again collectively in the long run, this episode and this stretch of the sport are the cementing of the connection between Joel and Ellie that the story wants earlier than it heads into its ultimate chapter. That’s subsequent week, after we’ll lastly settle the discourse about whether or not or not Joel’s actions are justified as soon as and for all. See you then.
