Starfleet Academy Cancellation Explained By Robert Picardo

Spread the love

Robert Picardo speaks out about the “sad news” that Star Trek: Starfleet Academy season 2 will be the final season. Just 12 days after Star Trek: Starfleet Academy‘s season 1 finale premiered, Paramount+ announced it would not be renewing the young adult-focused Star Trek series for season 3.

Reprising his iconic role as The Doctor from Star Trek: Voyager, Robert Picardo was the bridge from Star Trek‘s past to the optimistic future of the 32nd century. Haughty as ever, The Doctor evolved in Star Trek: Starfleet Academy season 1, coming to terms with 800-year-old trauma from the USS Voyager and choosing to become a parent to SAM (Kerrice Brooks), a cadet and fellow holographic being.

Appearing on the On Screen and Beyond podcast to hype his March 28th appearance at the Orinda Theater to celebrate the works of director Joe Dante, Robert Picardo eloquently detailed his thoughts about Star Trek: Starfleet Academy‘s cancellation, why the “present political and cultural climate” seems to have worked against the show, and his faith that Starfleet Academy will be “viewed and valued as a real gem” in the future. Read Bob’s quotes below:

Robert Picardo: “We got some sad news this week and that is that our show is not being extended beyond the second season. I think our show is very much in the tradition of all of Star Trek. It is very diverse and inclusive, and I think some of those values are not, how should I put it, are not as popular in the present political and cultural climate in America. Which is unusual because those are the core values of Star Trek. That’s always what [Gene] Roddenberry valued the most, was diversity. He said it in many quotes.

But now it seems that the pendulum is swinging a little the other way and our show is not picked up. There will be no new Star Trek for a while, and then Star Trek will come back. But I hope that it does come back with the same core values that it’s always embodied, and have always been really essential to Roddenberry’s optimistic vision of humanity’s future in space.

It’s a vision where science and technology empower humanity [so] that they don’t destroy it. So science has to be alive and vital. Some say that science is even under attack in our present political and cultural movement. But also it’s a future in which we are valued not for the color of our skin or our sexual preferences but for the content of our character and what we contribute to the crew, to the collective. And all of those core values of Star Trek I hope will be there in whatever new Star Trek there is in the future.

I’ve been proud to be a part of the franchise for more than 30 years now. That’s more [than half] of its 60 year life that we are celebrating this year. This September will be the 60th anniversary of the first broadcast of Star Trek.

[Starfleet Academy] the show, the work of the show is extraordinary. And even though, as I said, it didn’t quite fit in with this current political, cultural moment we’re having in America, I think the show will be viewed and valued as a real gem in the future. Eventually, the pendulum always swings back towards Star Trek’s original core values. I’m just sorry we didn’t make more episodes, as we could and, I believe, we should have.”

Robert Picardo also praised William Shatner, who expressed his “sorrow” about Star Trek: Starfleet Academy‘s cancellation on X:

Robert Picardo: “I’ve gotten to know William Shatner quite a bit better. I’ve known him for 30 years, but we had a great dinner together on the recent Star Trek Cruise, and I can’t say enough things about how vital and engaged he is. At 95 years old, he has a childlike enthusiasm about learning new things, meeting new people, conversing with someone in a vastly different art or profession than he’s in that he finds interesting. He’s a great lesson in how to stay young, I think, being around him. So hopefully, I can employ some of those new lessons I’ve learned moving forward.”

Watch Robert Picardo’s On Screen and Beyond podcast interview below:

On X, William Shatner pointed out Star Trek‘s historical cycle of a vocal segment of fans greeting each new iteration of Star Trek with hostility. This was the case with Star Trek: The Next Generation onward. Star Trek: Starfleet Academy, as a show, and its diverse cast, young and old, were targeted with hateful, racist, and homophobic comments online.

Along with Robert Picardo’s rationale that the changing political and cultural climate factored into Star Trek: Starfleet Academy’s cancellation, viewership was also a prevalent issue. According to Variety, Star Trek: Starfleet Academy couldn’t “find a significant audience” and failed to chart in the Nielsen Streaming Top 10.

Production of Star Trek: Starfleet Academy is now over after filming of season 2 wrapped in late February. The remaining 10 episodes of what is now Star Trek: Starfleet Academy‘s second and final season are expected to premiere in early 2027 on Paramount+.

Unfortunately, executive producers and co-showrunners Alex Kurtzman and Noga Landau designed Star Trek: Starfleet Academy as a four-year story to reflect a college experience. Star Trek: Starfleet Academy will now end during the cadets’ sophomore year, and reportedly with a cliffhanger.

As Robert Picardo also explained, with no new Star Trek TV series currently in production or greenlit, Star Trek could “go away” for a while after the final seasons of Star Trek: Starfleet Academy and Star Trek: Strange New Worlds premiere on Paramount+ in 2027.

Hopefully, the next iteration of Star Trek will still reflect Gene Roddenberry’s progressive and inclusive vision of an optimistic future, as Star Trek: Starfleet Academy does. Time will, indeed, be kind to Captain Nahla Ake (Holly Hunter) and her cadets.