‘One Superb Morning’ Is Sensible And Touching, Besides When It is Not

Sony Photos Classics

As a part of our protection of the forty seventh annual Toronto Worldwide Movie Competition, Anna Swanson evaluations Mia Hansen-Løve’s newest movie, One Superb Morning. Observe together with extra protection in our Toronto Worldwide Movie Competition archives.

There’s a wonderful line between sympathy and pity. It may well’t all the time be measured by something definable, however if you expertise compassion verging into condescension, you realize the distinction. Mia Hansen-Løve is a filmmaker who definitely is aware of that distinction and has spent her profession sustaining a spot on the facet of compassion. The French filmmaker tends to assemble movies about girls navigating familial and/or romantic relationships. In her tales, key dramatic moments might be turbulent life-changing occasions or the bittersweet truths of on a regular basis life. What has constantly endeared her movies to viewers is that she all the time finds compassion for her characters, however she by no means appears down on them. In her newest, One Superb Morning, inspecting pity however not giving into it’s the key matter at hand.

The movie follows Lea Seydoux‘s Sandra, a Parisian single mom tasked with aiding her father, Georg (Pascal Greggory), as his well being declines. A former philosophy professor, Georg has been identified with Benson’s syndrome, a illness much like Alzheimer’s. Sandra and the remainder of the household attempt to preserve Georg snug and cared for, however with him shuffling between private and non-private care amenities, it may be tough to determine what is definitely finest for him.

Although Sandra is implored by her personal grandmother throughout a go to to all the time resist pitying others, this precept is strained by her father’s circumstances. There’s a transparent quantity of familial love (even Sandra’s mom, divorced from Georg for many years, tries to assist him), however as his situation worsens, Sandra struggles with retaining a way of who her father was earlier than.

Additional complicating all of it is that Sandra is caught in her personal net of tangled interpersonal relationships. She has an opportunity encounter with Clement (Melvil Poupaud), a former good friend of her late husband, and begins her personal friendship with him. Together with her having spent the final 5 years alone and him in a wedding that’s misplaced its spark, it doesn’t take lengthy for the platonic relationship to progress to one thing extra. Although Sandra insists what they’ve isn’t just a easy fling, that’s the way it initially presents. The stress comes from Clement teetering between his new passionate affair and the dedication he made to his spouse, to not point out the complication of getting a toddler at dwelling.

It’s their relationship that, sadly, sucks the air out of what’s in any other case a compelling and considerate drama. The connection between Sandra and Clement always feels torn between opposing readings of their dynamic. From the second they meet, it appears clear that this isn’t the muse of a wholesome relationship. She’s single however rattled by the developments along with her father and really emotionally uncooked. He’s married with a child. If there was a real spark of ardour between them, maybe it could be comprehensible that they fall into an entanglement, however the chemistry doesn’t appear to be there. And it’s not that Hansen-Løve isn’t adept at capturing the chemistry between her characters; for proof, look no additional than final yr’s Bergman Island.

However in fact, the connection doesn’t need to be a torrid, passionate affair to be compelling. Whereas Sandra is enchanted by Clement from the beginning, he retains her at a distance. He returns to his spouse after which, earlier than lengthy, comes again to Sandra on a number of events. Her desperation does certainly provoke concepts round Sandra as the topic of pity, however this comes throughout as an afterthought, particularly when contextualized within the filmmaker’s physique of labor.

Sandra and Clement’s dynamic, one the place she is dedicated to him, and he sees her as an choice, was explored brilliantly in Hansen-Løve’s coming-of-age drama Goodbye First Love. Within the 2011 movie, it was youthful naivete that stored one half of a pair dedicated to the opposite regardless of the pink flags. In One Superb Morning, Sandra’s fragile emotional state makes her cling to a connection, even when Clement has proven his willingness to discard her.

Nonetheless, whereas Goodbye First Love tackled these concepts with depth, perception, and empathy, the identical endeavor doesn’t occur in One Superb Morning. The truth that Sandra’s priorities are cut up between her household and her relationship (to not point out her little one and her job) is sensible to the load that she shoulders as an grownup. However it additionally signifies that there isn’t sufficient screentime dedicated to her relationship with Clement to create an funding within the final result of their affair. As an alternative, Sandra and Clement come throughout because the CliffsNotes model of a relationship dynamic that Hansen-Løve has already explored in a way more compelling manner elsewhere.

Although the movie general might not measure up in opposition to Hansen-Løve’s finest work, there’s all the time one thing enriching to be present in her movies. In One Superb Morning, for instance, a second to cherish revolves round a monologue from Sandra about how her father’s expansive assortment of books is extra him than he’s at this level. Whereas his deteriorating well being has claimed his thoughts, his library — the books he cared for, the issues that enriched him and that he, in flip, handed on to others — is what Sandra holds on to. She’s in a position to regard his books with a passion that she will be able to’t all the time conjure for the person himself. It’s a heartbreaking and sincere element from a filmmaker who tends to excel at precisely these qualities. To low cost the worth of those moments due to different faults within the movie — now that will be an actual pity.

Associated Subjects: Toronto Worldwide Movie Competition (TIFF)

Anna Swanson is a Senior Contributor who hails from Toronto. She will be able to normally be discovered on the nearest rep screening of a Brian De Palma movie.